- Everyday Alpha
- Posts
- The Sell Ratings Are In, But The Margins Say Something Else
The Sell Ratings Are In, But The Margins Say Something Else
Three banks just told you to sell this brand. Its margins quietly went the other way.
When three big banks cut a stock in the same week, most investors take the hint and stop looking. That's usually when the interesting setups start.
This one comes with a dividend yield near the highest it has offered in many years, a balance sheet with billions in cash, and a gross margin that actually improved last quarter while sales shrank.
One Stock Benefits (Sponsored)
Elon Musk says reports of a new SpaceX phone-like device are “utterly false.”
But one analyst believes recent FCC filings and trademarks tell a different story.
He thinks they point toward a new device that could create a major investing opportunity before the broader market catches on.
And he has identified one stock he believes could benefit most.
See the filings, trademarks, and stock behind his prediction here.
NIKE, Inc.
October 14 – Pre‑market
Ticker: NKE | Sector: Consumer Cyclical (Footwear & Apparel) | Market Cap: $52.48B
30‑Second Take
Why now? Nike reported its fiscal first quarter on October 1 and guided full-year revenue down by a high-single-digit percentage.
The stock dropped to a fresh 52-week low the next day, and the downgrades followed: Goldman Sachs went to Sell with a $27.50 target, Bank of America cut its objective to $24, and Morgan Stanley trimmed to $27.
The headlines skipped one detail. Gross margin expanded 60 basis points to 42.8% even as revenue fell 4% to $11.2 billion. Nike is shrinking on purpose, pulling back on discounting and old franchises, and the margin line is the first sign that the cleanup is working.
You're not betting on a quick rebound in sales. You're betting that the bad news is now in the price, with a roughly 4.6% dividend paying you while the turnaround plays out.
Trade Setup
Timeframe: 3 to 6 months (into and through the mid-December report)
Edge type: Contrarian income entry after a wave of downgrades
The setup works only if the floor near the 52-week low holds. Treat a decisive break below it as the signal that the market sees something worse than what's already in the guidance.
One piece of color: on October 9, options traders bought about $1.1 million of calls spread across the $35.50, $40, and $42.50 strikes, the largest a $42.50 call expiring March 2027. That's a useful tell about where some bigger money is leaning, but it isn't the thesis.
Critical Minerals (Sponsored)
Around $5 a share, one small company. Wall Street, for the most part, is still missing the link.
Name the company for me
Humanoid robots, electric cars by the millions, thousands of satellites, reusable boosters — all depend on a handful of metals America is short of.
Elon Musk can build the rockets. The metal he cannot dig up, and it funnels through one narrow point.
This ad is sent on behalf of Guardian Financial Publishing LLC, doing business as Stable Financial Publishing, 1013 Centre Road Suite 403-D, Wilmington, DE 19805. Nothing here is investment, financial, legal, or tax advice, and it is not a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any security. Investing involves substantial risk, including loss of principal; small-cap and low-priced stocks carry particular risk, including the possible loss of your entire investment. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Stable Financial Publishing, its owners, employees and contributors may hold positions in securities mentioned and may trade them at any time. References to Elon Musk and SpaceX are for informational purposes only; Stable Financial Publishing is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Elon Musk or SpaceX. Privacy: https://guardian.pub/privacy-policy/ · Terms: https://guardian.pub/terms-of-service/
Social Security retirement benefits are calculated based on a worker's highest how many years of earnings? |
Snapshot Table
Metric | Value | Current Stance |
|---|---|---|
Price | $35.33 | Near its 52-week low |
52-Week Range | $31.97 - $70.44 | Bottom of the range |
Market Cap | $52.48B | Mega-brand at a decade-low valuation |
P/E Ratio | 17x trailing, ~28x FY27 guided EPS | Earnings still falling |
Dividend Yield | 4.6% ($1.64 annual) | 24 straight years of raises |
Beta | 1.1 | Roughly market-like volatility |
Avg Daily Volume | 31M (3-month) | Very liquid |
Next Catalyst | Fiscal Q2 report, mid-December (date TBC) | Is the margin still expanding? |
Chart
1-Month Trading Summary: NKE is down about 5% over the past month and roughly 44% this year. Most of that damage came before last week. Since the post-earnings low, the stock has been chopping sideways in the mid-$30s even as the downgrades rolled in.
Volume has been heavy, averaging about 31 million shares a day over the past three months. When a stock stops falling on a string of Sell ratings, sellers may finally be running out of steam.
Bull Case
Why It Works
Nike is still the biggest name in athletic footwear, and management is deliberately making the business smaller before it grows again. Fewer markdowns, tighter inventory and less reliance on aging sneaker franchises cost revenue today. They also show up as better margins, which is exactly what happened last quarter.
The balance sheet gives the company time. Nike ended the quarter with about $8.4 billion in cash and short-term investments, so this is a slow fix, not a funding problem.
The Catalysts
The next real test is fiscal second-quarter results in mid-December. Nike hasn't confirmed the date yet. With guidance already cut and three banks on the sidelines, the bar for a positive surprise is about as low as it gets. Holiday sell-through reads from retailers in November and December will give you an early look.
The dividend decision is the other one to watch. Nike has raised its payout for 24 straight years and usually announces the increase in November. Even a token raise would signal that management sees the earnings bottoming.
What The Numbers Say
Nike trades around 17 times trailing earnings, well below where it traded for most of the past decade. The average analyst target sits near $38, a little above where shares trade now even after last week's cuts.
The yield does the heavy lifting. At about 4.6%, you get paid a meaningful income while you wait for the margin story to reach the revenue line.
Bear Case
What Could Break It
Goldman's argument is structural, not about one quarter. The bank says Nike appears to have accepted a smaller place in sportswear as brands like On, Hoka and New Balance take share. If that's right, a cheap stock can stay cheap for a long time.
China remains a weak spot, and Jordan Brand and the big sportswear lines are still shrinking. Another guidance cut in December would likely send the stock through its 52-week low.
The Valuation Risk
The trailing multiple flatters Nike because earnings are falling. Management's adjusted earnings guidance of $1.15 to $1.35 a share puts the stock closer to 28 times this year's profit, and the $1.64 annual dividend is above that range. Nike can fund the payout from cash for a while, but a raise is not guaranteed, and a freeze would remove part of the income case.
How To Size It
Start with a partial position and treat it as an income-plus-turnaround holding, not a quick trade. If the stock breaks the 52-week low on heavy volume, step aside and revisit after the December report.
If it holds and the November dividend news is constructive, add in steps. Don't size it as if the turnaround is already confirmed.
Quick Checklist
✅ 52-week low holding on a closing basis
✅ November dividend announcement (24-year raise streak on the line)
✅ Holiday sell-through commentary from retail partners
✅ Fiscal Q2 report in mid-December: is the gross margin still expanding?
Deep‑Dive Links
That’s all for today’s Everyday Alpha. We’ll have a new pick for you every morning before the market opens, so stay tuned!
Best Regards,
—Noah Zelvis
Everyday Alpha