From Oranges to Opportunity: This Florida Land Story Is Ripe for Repricing

In partnership with

Introducing the first AI-native CRM

Connect your email, and you’ll instantly get a CRM with enriched customer insights and a platform that grows with your business.

With AI at the core, Attio lets you:

• Prospect and route leads with research agents

• Get real-time insights during customer calls

• Build powerful automations for your complex workflows

Join industry leaders like Granola, Taskrabbit, Flatfile and more.

👉Try Attio Pro for free

30‑Second Take

If you think of Florida agriculture, you probably picture oranges. Us too, but Alico's story is shifting far beyond the groves.

Once defined by its citrus roots, this 90-year-old company is quietly reinventing itself as a land-and-resources powerhouse. 

With 54,000 acres of land devoted to farming, conservation, natural resources, and targeted real estate across the Sunshine State, Alico’s real value may lie in what’s beneath and beyond the trees.

That means mineral rights, leases, and conservation land that could turn idle soil into steady income.

So why now? As citrus headwinds linger and land values keep rising, Alico’s slow-burn transformation could start to catch the market’s eye.

It’s a patient investor’s story, the kind where execution takes time, but the payoff could come from the dirt itself.

Trade Setup

Timeframe: Medium to long term
Edge Type: Asset value rerating with transformation play

This is a classic patient investor setup. You’re not chasing momentum; you’re backing a company in transition. 

If you’re tolerant of illiquidity and lagging headlines, ALCO offers exposure to Florida’s real-asset upside without paying property-developer premiums.

Think of it as a slow-burn value story, not a quick trade, the kind that rewards patience and an eye for underappreciated land plays.

Snapshot Table

Chart

1-month trading summary: Over the past month, Alico’s stock has inched higher, climbing 6.56% as investors warmed to its slow-but-steady turnaround story.

The move hasn’t been explosive (think gentle Florida breeze), but it’s been consistent, with shares steadily moving from the low $33s to around $35.76 by late October.

Volume’s been light, suggesting this isn’t a momentum crowd piling in, but rather patient hands nibbling at a name that’s still flying under the radar.

For a thinly-traded agribusiness, that quiet upward drift hints at growing confidence in Alico’s long-term shift from citrus production toward land and asset optimization.

Bull Case 

Unlocking hidden value (above and below the surface): The bullish case for Alico is all about uncovering value.

Beneath the surface of its citrus groves lies a vast and underappreciated asset base, more than 50,000 acres of Florida land plus nearly as many acres of mineral rights. 

As the company steps away from volatile citrus production and leans into land sales, leases, and conservation programs, it’s essentially transforming from a grower into a land monetization business with recurring income potential.

If management continues to trim costs, sell non-core acreage, and ink new long-term agreements, Alico could see margins stabilize and cash flow improve even without big swings in crop output. 

Add in the rising value of Florida land, driven by population growth, development, and conservation demand, and you've got a patient investor's play on tangible assets meeting strategic execution.

The biggest spark: If Alico keeps hitting its milestones, the upside could build fast.

The biggest potential spark is fresh land and mineral rights deals, which could reveal the true value of its 50,000+ acres in Florida and shift how the market values the business.

Add in the likelihood of new conservation and leasing agreements for steady, recurring revenue, and you've got a foundation for rerating.

If upcoming quarters show even modest profit growth or cost reductions as citrus winds down, confidence could snowball. 

With Florida land prices continuing to climb, Alico sits in the sweet spot of owning scarce, appreciating real estate at a time when investors are craving hard-asset exposure.

Price targets: Current targets range from $35.00 to $44.00. 

Quietly constructive technicals: Technically, Alico’s chart is quietly constructive.

After finding support in the low $33 range in late September, the stock has trended steadily higher, closing out October near $36.00. 

The stock is also trading above the 50-day and 200-day moving averages, signaling improving momentum, while the RSI sits in the mid-60s, suggesting there’s still room to run before things look overheated.

What we’re seeing here is subtle strength building beneath the surface, much like the company itself.

Bear Case 

A slow transformation with growing pains: The most significant risk for Alico is simple: the turnaround takes longer (or delivers less) than investors hope.

Transitioning from a traditional citrus producer to a diversified land and resource manager isn’t a quick fix. 

Revenue from land sales and conservation projects can be unpredictable. It is also highly dependent on timing and regulatory approvals.

If those deals stall or the market for Florida land cools, Alico could find itself sitting on valuable assets that don’t translate into near-term earnings.

On top of that, the citrus business, which still underpins part of its operations, remains exposed to disease, weather volatility, and soft commodity pricing.

That’s a cocktail that can sour margins quickly. 

Raising the bar on execution: When it comes to competition, Alico’s risks are less about direct rivals and more about better-capitalized land players moving faster on similar opportunities.

Companies like Gladstone Land Corporation (LAND) or Farmland Partners (FPI) already have scale, investor recognition, and REIT structures that make it easier to raise capital and deploy it efficiently.

Those peers can scoop up attractive properties, negotiate better lease terms, or monetize assets more quickly.

Familiar headwinds challenge growth: Rising interest rates and financing costs make it tougher to monetize or refinance land assets, cooling enthusiasm for slower-growth agribusiness plays.

At the same time, volatile commodity prices and ongoing climate pressures in Florida’s agriculture sector keep a lid on near-term optimism, even for land-rich names like Alico.

A lack of liquidity defined the crowded trade concern: With most investors chasing tech and yield-heavy REITs, few are paying attention to small-cap land plays like Alico.

That lack of liquidity can cut both ways: it leaves room for a sharp rerating if sentiment turns, but also means any hiccup could send the stock sliding faster than fundamentals justify.

Quick Checklist 

✅ Thesis still valid after today’s close
✅ Volume confirms move above key levels
✅ Catalyst date double-checked (October 27, 2025)

Deep‑Dive Links

• Q3 2025 Earnings 

• Analyst Ratings and Price Targets

• Short Interest Data

• Company Profile and Investor Relations

That’s all for today’s Everyday Alpha. We’ll have a new pick for you every morning before the market opens, so stay tuned!

Best Regards,
—Noah Zelvis
Everyday Alpha